In an 1822 letter to the doctor Benjamin Waterhouse, Thomas Jefferson expressed his confidence that conventional Christianity within the younger United States was giving approach to a extra enlightened religion, very similar to Jefferson’s personal in its rejection of the divinity of Jesus Christ. “I belief,” he wrote, “that there’s not a younger man now dwelling within the U.S. who won’t die an Unitarian.”

Lower than a yr earlier, on “a Sabbath night within the autumn of 1821” in upstate New York, a younger man named Charles Grandison Finney started a multiday interaction of prayer and mystical expertise that ‌‌led to a second when, he wrote later, “it appeared as if I met the Lord Jesus Christ head to head … He stood earlier than me, and I fell down at his ft and poured out my soul to Him. I wept aloud like a toddler, and made such confessions as I might with my choked utterance.”

This expertise set Finney on a path that may assist bury Jefferson’s assured speculation — towards management in an age of revivalism, the Second Nice Awakening, that solid the type of evangelical Christianity that may bestride Nineteenth-century America and likewise inspired a proliferation of novel sects with supernatural beliefs fully distant from Jefferson’s Enlightenment faith.

That historical past is value mentioning for a particular motive and a basic one. The particular motive is {that a} Christian school in rural Kentucky, Asbury College, has simply skilled an old-school revival — a multiweek outpouring that has stored college students praying and singing within the faculty chapel from morning to nighttime, drawn ten of hundreds of pilgrims from across the nation, captured the creativeness of the web and even drawn the eye of The New York Occasions.

The overall motive is that regardless of the Asbury Revival’s long-term impression, the historical past of Finney and Jefferson is a reminder that non secular historical past is formed as a lot by sudden irruptions as lengthy trajectories, as a lot by the magical and private as by the institutional and sociological.

Secular consultants writing about faith have a tendency to emphasise the deep structural forces shaping apply and perception — the results of industrialization or the scientific revolution, suburbanization or the contraception tablet. Spiritual intellectuals have a tendency to emphasise theological debates and evangelization methods. (Ought to Christians be winsome or combative? Ought to church buildings adapt to liberal modernity or resist its blandishments?)

These analytical instruments are all the time necessary; the sociological doesn’t disappear simply because the magical has instantly arrived. In final weekend’s column, as an illustration, I recommended a hyperlink between the obvious disaster in teenage psychological well being and the decline of organized Christianity, and this week my colleague Ruth Graham, reporting from Asbury, notes that accounts of therapeutic on the revival are “overwhelmingly about psychological well being, trauma and disillusionment.” Nor, within the shadow of the numinous, does technique stop to matter: The encounter on the highway to Damascus created Paul the Apostle, however his profession thereafter was all organizing, preaching, letter-writing and shoe (or sandal) leather-based.

However the experiences themselves stay irreducibly unpredictable. Why Asbury? Why Saul of Tarsus? Why Charles Grandison Finney?

A novel non secular tradition exists throughout the Mountain West as a result of one in all Finney’s upstate New York contemporaries believed he obtained a revelation from the angel Moroni. Arguably crucial motion inside international Christianity at this time exists due to a revival that started with an African-American preacher and his followers praying collectively in a shabby a part of Los Angeles in 1906. And I can quote you chapter and verse on the reasonability of theism, however within the causal chain of historical past I’m a Christian as a result of two thousand years in the past a motley group of provincials in Roman Palestine believed they’d seen their instructor heal the sick and lift the useless after which rise transfigured from the grave — after which as a result of, two millenniums later, as a toddler in suburban Connecticut, I watched my very own mother and father fall to the ground and converse in tongues.

Whether or not these experiences correspond to final actuality won’t be argued right here. My factors are about remark and expectation.

In the case of the non secular future, you need to observe the social tendencies, but additionally all the time anticipate the surprising — recognizing that each organized religion might disappear tomorrow and a few religious encounter would resurrect faith quickly sufficient.

When you’re making an attempt to discern what a post-Christian spirituality would possibly turn out to be, then what post-Christian seekers are experiencing and what (or whom) they declare to be encountering issues as a lot as any particular non secular label they could declare.

And when you’re imagining a renewal for American Christianity, all the most effective laid plans — the pastoral methods, theological debates and long-term trendlines — could matter lower than one thing taking place in some obscure place or to some obscure particular person, in whose visions a wholly surprising future could be taking form.

The Occasions is dedicated to publishing a range of letters to the editor. We’d like to listen to what you concentrate on this or any of our articles. Listed here are some ideas. And right here’s our e mail: letters@nytimes.com.

Comply with The New York Occasions Opinion part on Fb, Twitter (@NYTOpinion) and Instagram.